In a small city, the mayor is the person residents call when the water main breaks, when a big employer announces it’s leaving, and when a storm knocks out power on half the streets in town. Voters expect the mayor to have answers, even on issues the office doesn’t directly control.
That makes a mayoral race different from a school board or city council campaign. Council members share decisions with their colleagues. A mayor is held responsible for how the whole city runs, and voters choose accordingly.
At ActBlue, we’ve supported Democratic candidates for more than two decades, including many running for local executive office for the first time. The guide below walks you through how to understand the job, qualify for the ballot, and build a campaign that convinces voters you’re ready for it.
What does a mayor do?
Mayors are typically the chief elected official of a city. Depending on local law, a mayor may propose the budget, oversee city departments, appoint department heads and members of boards and commissions, sign or veto ordinances, and represent the city in dealings with the county, the state, and other governments.
In small cities or towns, the job is also more hands-on. City staff may be limited, and the mayor may be directly involved in everything from grant applications to economic development meetings to resident complaints about a pothole. Many small-city mayors serve part time, sometimes with modest pay, while holding another job. It helps to find out the time commitment and compensation for your city before you decide to run.
Understand your city’s form of government
The title “mayor” covers very different jobs from one city to the next. The city charter, along with state law, defines how much authority the office actually holds. The most common structures are:
- Strong mayor: The mayor is the city’s chief executive, runs daily operations, oversees departments, and usually proposes the budget and holds veto power.
- Weak mayor: The mayor presides over the council and represents the city, but executive authority is shared with the council or other elected officials.
- Council-manager: The council, often including the mayor, sets policy and hires a professional city manager to run operations. The mayor’s role is primarily to lead the council and serve as the city’s public representative.
Important: In some cities, the mayor isn’t elected directly by voters at all. The council selects one of its own members to serve as mayor. Confirm that your city holds a direct mayoral election before you plan a mayoral campaign.
Read your charter closely and watch several council meetings to see how the mayor actually works with the council and city staff. A candidate who promises to reorganize city departments in a council-manager city is promising something the mayor can’t deliver alone.
Confirm your eligibility
Eligibility rules are set by your city charter and state law. Most cities require mayoral candidates to be registered voters, meet a minimum age, and live in the city for a set period before the election. Some also address conflicts of interest, city employment, or outstanding debts to the city.
Your city clerk, county elections office, or state election authority can provide the current candidate guide. Use it to confirm:
- The qualifications to run and hold office
- The length of the term and whether term limits apply
- Whether the race is partisan or nonpartisan
- How the winner is decided, whether by plurality, a primary, a runoff, or ranked-choice voting
Many municipal elections are nonpartisan. In those races, your party won’t appear on the ballot, so voters will rely more on what they know about you.
Qualify for the ballot
Filing requirements for mayor are often similar to those for council, but they may involve more signatures, a higher fee, or additional disclosures. Depending on your city, you may need to:
- File a declaration of candidacy
- Pay a filing fee, or submit a petition in lieu of a fee
- Collect nomination petition signatures from registered voters in the city
- Appoint a treasurer and register a campaign committee
- File financial or economic-interest disclosures
Any registered voter in the city can typically sign your petition, which makes collection simpler than in a ward race. Petitions can still be rejected for incorrect addresses, unregistered signers, or formatting errors. Collect well above the minimum, set an internal deadline ahead of the official one, and review every page before you submit.
Use signature collection as an early test of your campaign. Knocking on doors and standing outside the grocery store for signatures will tell you how well known you are, which issues come up first, and who is willing to help.
Calculate your vote goal
Every voter in the city is part of your electorate, which makes the vote goal especially important. It tells you how many residents you need to reach and how to spend limited time and money doing it.
Start with results from the last several mayoral elections. How many people voted, how many candidates ran, and how many votes did the winner receive? Pay attention to the election calendar. Municipal elections held in odd years or on their own dates often draw far lower turnout than elections held alongside state or federal races, and a small shift in turnout can decide the outcome.
Then factor in how your city decides the winner. In a plurality race, you need more votes than any other candidate. If a majority is required, a crowded field may lead to a runoff, and your first goal may be simply to finish in the top two. In a ranked-choice race, second-choice support from other candidates’ voters can matter.
Set your target somewhat above what past winners received, then break it down by precinct or neighborhood. In a small city, that breakdown can be granular enough to guide individual canvass shifts.
Define your vision for the city
Voters expect a mayoral candidate to explain where the city should be headed. They’ll want to know what you’d prioritize in your first year, how you’d handle the budget, and what the city would look like after your term.
Start by learning the city’s finances. Small-city budgets are often tight, with much of the money committed to public safety, staff, and debt service before any new priority is funded. Review the current budget, the capital improvement plan, recent audits, and any major grants or state funding the city depends on.
Then listen across the city. Meet with residents in every neighborhood, small-business owners, city employees, first responders, faith leaders, school officials, and the people running local nonprofits. Ask what’s working, what isn’t, and what they want from city hall.
Choose two or three priorities you can explain clearly and back up with a plan. For each one, be ready to say what the city would do, what it would cost, where the money would come from, and how you’d work with the council to get it done. A specific plan for one problem will persuade more voters than an ambitious list with no details.
Earn endorsements and support
In a small city, voters often know candidates personally or know someone who does. Your reputation, your work history, and how you’ve treated people in the community will shape the race as much as your platform.
Voters want evidence that you can manage. Be ready to talk concretely about experience that shows you can handle a budget, lead people, make difficult decisions, and respond under pressure. That experience can come from a business, a nonprofit, a union, a school, the military, a city board or commission, or years of community leadership.
They’ll also want to know you can work with others. A mayor who can’t build a working relationship with the council will struggle to get anything done, whatever the city’s form of government. Meet with current council members and council candidates, and show that you can build consensus with people who don’t always agree with you.
Seek endorsements from people residents already know, such as longtime business owners, retired teachers, community leaders, and former public servants. In a small city, a handful of familiar local names often counts for more with voters than organizations they’ve never heard of.
Recruit your campaign team
A small-city mayoral campaign rarely has paid staff, but it still needs more structure than a council race. You’re running citywide, you’ll face more scrutiny, and you’ll be juggling fundraising, press, and canvassing at the same time. Fill these roles early, even if most of them are volunteers:
- Campaign manager: Runs the calendar, keeps volunteers on task, and makes sure the plan gets carried out. The most important trait is organization, not campaign experience. Your manager should be someone who can tell you no and who isn’t also the person you’re asking to knock doors every weekend.
- Treasurer: Most states and cities require one before you can raise or spend money. Your treasurer handles the campaign bank account, tracks contributions, and files finance reports on time. Choose someone careful with details, since late or incorrect reports can become a campaign issue.
- Fundraising lead: Keeps your donor list, schedules your call time, follows up on pledges, and helps plan events. In a small race, this may be your treasurer or a well-connected supporter, but someone besides you should own the list.
- Communications lead: Handles the local paper, radio, and community newsletters, manages your social media, and helps you prepare for forums. Mayoral candidates get more press attention than other local candidates, so you’ll want someone ready to respond quickly.
- Volunteer coordinator and neighborhood captains: Recruits and schedules volunteers and organizes canvass shifts. Ask one supporter in each neighborhood to serve as a captain, someone who can recruit neighbors, host a gathering, and keep that part of the city covered.
If you can, recruit a few trusted advisors who know how city hall works: a former council member, someone who has served on a city board or commission, or someone with municipal finance experience. They can help you understand the budget, prepare for tough questions, and avoid promises the office can’t deliver.
Start fundraising
A mayoral campaign has to reach every household in the city, so it usually needs more money than a council race. Set a fundraising goal early and break it into monthly targets. That way, you’ll know whether you’re on pace to afford mail and literature by the time voters start paying attention.
Start by writing out everyone you know who lives in or cares about the city: family, friends, neighbors, coworkers, your congregation, the parents from your kid’s soccer team. Call each one, tell them why you want to lead the city, and ask for a specific amount.
Then, shift focus on building support across the city, not just in your own neighborhood. Ask supporters in different parts of town to host small gatherings for their neighbors, and reach out to small-business owners, retirees, and community leaders who care how the city is run. A few well-connected supporters can serve as a finance committee, each committing to raise a set amount from their own networks.
Launch your campaign website
Voters who hear about your campaign at the grocery store, in a Facebook group, or from a neighbor will look you up. Your campaign website should answer their questions quickly:
- Who you are and your connection to the city
- Why you’re running for mayor
- Your two or three priorities and how you’d accomplish them
- The experience that prepares you to lead
- Ways to donate, volunteer, and contact the campaign
- When and how to vote
- Required campaign disclaimers
Explain what the mayor actually does in your city, especially if the office’s powers are limited. Voters will trust your platform more if it’s clear you understand the job.
Organize a citywide field program
In a small city, the candidate can personally reach a large share of the voters needed to win. Make door-to-door canvassing the core of your field program, map turf so every neighborhood is covered, and put the candidate on as many shifts as the schedule allows.
Word travels through informal networks in a small city: congregations, youth sports leagues, civic clubs, and local Facebook groups. Relational organizing, where volunteers reach out to people they already know, is especially effective in these places. Ask every volunteer to make a list of friends and neighbors they can personally talk to about the race.
Use phone banking, texting, candidate forums, and local media, including the local paper, radio station, or community newsletter, to reach voters you missed at the door and give them more chances to see you.
Track every conversation so you know where your support is strong and which neighborhoods need more attention. ActBlue Field Tools helps campaigns coordinate canvassing, texting, phone banking, relational organizing, and volunteers across the city.
Common mistakes first-time mayoral candidates should avoid
- Ignoring the council: Most of what a mayor wants to accomplish requires council votes. Voters notice when a candidate seems more interested in fighting the council than working with it.
- Relying on name recognition: Candidates who are well known around town sometimes skip the work of asking for votes. Knock doors and ask directly. Voters who know your name still need a reason to choose you.
- Running against city staff: Criticizing how the city is run is fair game, but attacking the employees who run it can backfire. If you win, those are the people you’ll lead, and in a small city, their friends and families vote.
- Running on a single issue: A fight over one development or one tax increase can launch a campaign, but voters are choosing someone to run the whole city. Show them you’re ready for everything else that lands on the mayor’s desk.
- Letting local social media set your agenda: Community Facebook groups can be useful for listening, but responding to every post or argument pulls you away from voter contact and can create controversies that follow you to the doors.
What should your mayoral campaign timeline include?
- Before filing: Read the charter, study the budget, and attend council meetings. Confirm the election rules, review past results, and begin quiet conversations with residents, local leaders, and potential team members.
- Filing and launch: Complete your paperwork, collect signatures if required, and set up your campaign finances. Launch your website and fundraising, and announce with a clear statement of why you’re running and what you’d do as mayor.
- Building support: Recruit volunteers, meet with community groups, and seek endorsements from local leaders. Start canvassing early, and use what you hear to sharpen your priorities.
- Final 90 days: Increase voter contact and track progress against your vote goal. Prepare for candidate forums and local press, and make sure your budget will carry the campaign through Election Day.
- Final 30 days: Follow up with undecided voters, confirm your supporters, and share accurate information about early voting, mail voting, and polling places.
- Election Day and beyond: Help supporters get to the polls and thank everyone who contributed to the campaign. Regardless of the result, file every required financial report. If you win, start planning your transition right away. The new term may begin within weeks.
Turn your decision to run into a mayoral campaign
Small-city mayoral races are won by candidates voters can picture in the job: someone who knows the city’s finances, can work with the council, and shows up in every neighborhood. The earlier you start knocking doors and building relationships, the more time you have to make that case.
ActBlue’s down-ballot tools help you build a citywide campaign on a small-city budget: Raise to bring in contributions from local supporters, Website Builder to show voters your plan for the city, and Field Tools to organize volunteers and reach voters in every neighborhood.
This post is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Campaign practices — including voter contact, data use, and fundraising — are governed by federal, state, and local law that varies by jurisdiction and changes over time. You are responsible for your campaign’s compliance. Consult your own legal counsel with legal questions.
Built for you. Built to win.
- Fundraising
- Field Tools
- Website Builder
